6 Comments
User's avatar
Deborah Roberts's avatar

It's exhausting to keep up with who's been cancelled. I'd rather just evaluate/enjoy the talent than worry about how someone painted Emmet Till or whether Virginia Wolff was anti-semitic.

I appreciate any review that tells the truth as the reviewer sees it and gives me the information to make a decision, in this case not to read the book. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Joy in HK fiFP's avatar

Woman and genius? None other than Mary Ann Evans, AKA, George Eliot. There are very few of any gender who can keep pace with her brilliance. If they didn't spot her at first look, somebody wasn't looking too hard.

Expand full comment
Moravagine's avatar

From the comments about fabric art and the like it sounds either like you have not looked much into Louise Bourgeois or have, but for some reason don’t want to invoke her name.

Expand full comment
Michael Goodwin Hilton's avatar

Interesting review. I'm halfway through "Vivienne" at present. I'll reserve complete judgment until the end. I share some of these reservations, but still find the work quite intriguing. There is a certain ambivalence throughout, though I don't know if I see it as the author being tentative, or even tame, so much as grappling with a larger cultural ambivalence toward strangeness and controversy, and really art itself. I think it's fair to say that commentary is more dominant than character in the novel, a critique I probably share. It feels like Russo may be grappling with her own cancelation via Vivienne, which are the elements of the novel that so far feel most alive. So mixed feelings thus far, but definitely encouraged to continue.

Expand full comment
Michael Goodwin Hilton's avatar

I find it pretty brilliant how Russo uses tweets to reveal backstory. Haven't quite encountered that yet in fiction.

Expand full comment
Prince Kudu’Ra's avatar

Joan d’Arc? Harriet Tubman? Mme Marie Laveau? CJ Walker?

Expand full comment